Plant-Based vs. Animal Protein: Myths, Benefits, and Best Sources for Muscle Growth & Health

Written By INNER G

The debate over plant-based versus animal-based protein has been a hot topic in health and fitness circles. Some claim that plant-based proteins are inadequate for muscle growth and overall health, while others argue that a well-planned plant-based diet can provide all essential amino acids. In this article, we will explore the differences between plant and animal proteins, debunk common myths about soy, and examine the role of key amino acids in body composition.

We will also compare the amino acid profiles of plant and animal protein sources and discuss how individuals can optimize their protein intake—whether they follow a plant-based or omnivorous diet.

Top Plant-Based and Animal-Based Protein Sources

Plant-Based Protein Sources (Per 100g)

  1. Lentils - 25g of protein

  2. Chickpeas - 19g of protein

  3. Quinoa - 14g of protein

  4. Tofu - 8g of protein

  5. Tempeh - 19g of protein

Animal-Based Protein Sources (Per 100g)

  1. Chicken Breast - 31g of protein

  2. Salmon - 25g of protein

  3. Eggs - 13g of protein

  4. Beef - 26g of protein

  5. Greek Yogurt - 10g of protein

Amino Acid Profiles

Protein quality is largely determined by its essential amino acid composition. Below is a breakdown of key amino acids present in various plant and animal protein sources.

Key Essential Amino Acids

  • Leucine: Crucial for muscle protein synthesis

  • Lysine: Supports immune function and collagen production

  • Methionine: Essential for metabolism and detoxification

  • Phenylalanine: Precursor to neurotransmitters

  • Tryptophan: Necessary for serotonin production

  • Threonine: Supports digestive and immune function

  • Valine: Important for muscle growth and energy

While plant-based proteins contain all essential amino acids, some may be low in lysine or methionine. However, by combining complementary protein sources—such as lentils and rice or quinoa and beans—individuals can obtain a complete amino acid profile.

The Myth of Soy Protein Deficiency

One of the biggest misconceptions about plant-based protein is that soy is harmful or nutritionally inadequate.

Soy and Muscle Mass

  • A study titled "Can We Maintain Muscle Mass on a Plant-Based Diet?" (Nour SI, 2025) examined muscle preservation on plant-based diets and found that soy protein was comparable to animal proteins in supporting lean muscle retention.

  • Soy contains all nine essential amino acids, making it one of the best plant-based protein sources.

  • Tempeh, a fermented soy product, provides highly bioavailable protein while also enhancing gut health due to its probiotic content.

The Truth About Trypsin Inhibitors

A common myth suggests that soy contains anti-nutrients like trypsin inhibitors that impair digestion and protein absorption. However:

  • Fermentation (as in tempeh) reduces trypsin inhibitors, improving digestibility.

  • Studies show that normal cooking and processing eliminate most of these inhibitors (Food Res Int, 2025).

  • The effect of trypsin inhibitors is minimal when soy is consumed as part of a varied diet.

Leucine: The Key Amino Acid for Muscle Growth

Leucine is often regarded as the most critical amino acid for muscle protein synthesis. According to a study from Current Nutrition Reports (2025):

  • Animal-based proteins, particularly chicken, beef, and fish, contain higher leucine levels per gram compared to most plant sources.

  • However, plant-based sources like tempeh, lentils, and quinoa still provide sufficient leucine for muscle growth.

  • To optimize plant-based protein intake, higher quantities may be required compared to animal protein sources.

Comparison: Plant-Based vs. Animal Protein for Body Composition

Muscle Growth & Recovery

  • Animal proteins have a higher bioavailability and contain a complete amino acid profile.

  • Plant proteins may require combining different sources to achieve optimal amino acid balance.

  • Soy protein isolate has been shown to stimulate muscle protein synthesis similarly to whey protein (Curr Dev Nutr, 2025).

Fat Loss & Satiety

  • Plant proteins tend to be higher in fiber, increasing satiety and supporting weight management.

  • Animal proteins provide higher leucine levels, which may enhance muscle retention during fat loss.

Longevity & Health

  • Some studies suggest that plant-based proteins are associated with lower inflammation and better heart health.

  • Overconsumption of red and processed meats has been linked to higher risks of cardiovascular disease.

The Role of Tempeh in a High-Protein Diet

Tempeh stands out as a top-tier plant-based protein because:

  • It is fermented, which reduces anti-nutrients and enhances digestion.

  • Contains 19g of protein per 100g, making it comparable to some animal sources.

  • Has a complete amino acid profile, unlike many other plant proteins.

  • Supports gut health due to probiotic content.

A 2025 study from Food Chemistry found that fermentation significantly enhances soy protein digestibility. This makes tempeh an ideal protein source for plant-based athletes and bodybuilders.

Final Thoughts: Which Protein Source is Better?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer—both plant and animal proteins have their advantages. However:

  • Animal proteins provide higher leucine and bioavailability.

  • Plant proteins can match animal protein effectiveness with proper combinations and increased intake.

  • Soy and tempeh are viable muscle-building proteins when consumed strategically.

For individuals looking to maximize muscle growth and overall health, combining high-quality plant proteins or incorporating animal sources in moderation may be the best approach.

Key Takeaways

✅ Soy is NOT harmful—it provides complete protein and health benefits
✅ Leucine is critical—animal sources have more, but plant sources can still provide enough
✅ Plant-based diets require strategic combinations for optimal protein intake
✅ Tempeh is a powerful plant-based protein with added probiotic benefits
✅ Both diets can support muscle growth and health when planned properly

REFERENCES

  1. Nour SI (2025). Can We Maintain Muscle Mass on a Plant-Based Diet? Current Nutrition Reports. DOI: 10.1007/s13668-024-00594-0

  2. Drewnowski A (2025). Milk and Dairy Provide Affordable High-Quality Protein. Current Developments in Nutrition. DOI: 10.1016/j.cdnut.2024.104539

  3. de Rosso VV (2025). Plant-Based Burgers: Nutrient Adequacy. Foods. DOI: 10.3390/foods14030372

  4. V AP (2025). Protein Extraction from Detoxified Cassava Leaves. Food Chemistry. DOI: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2025.143200

  5. Capanoglu E (2025). Towards Sustainable Plant Protein Sources: Rapeseed Review. Food Research International. DOI: 10.1016/j.foodres.2024.115553

  6. Liu YH (2020). Comparative Proteomics Provides Insights into Diapause Program in Bactrocera Minax. PloS One. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0244493

  7. Lei XG (2021). Replacing Fish Oil with Microalgal Sources Produced Different Metabolic Responses in Juvenile Trout. Journal of Animal Science. DOI: 10.1093/jas/skaa403

  8. Kim JK (2021). Treatment of Chemotherapy-Induced Cachexia with BST204: A Multimodal Validation Study. Metabolomics. DOI: 10.1007/s11306-021-01781-8

  9. Molist F (2023). Porcine Digestible Peptides as Alternative Protein Source in Weaner Diets. Animal. DOI: 10.1016/j.animal.2023.100998

  10. Gionbelli MP (2024). Maternal Protein Supplementation Improves Offspring Performance in Beef Cows. Journal of Animal Science. DOI: 10.1093/jas/skae058

  11. Huang SW (2018). Soy Protein Supplementation and Exercise Improve Bone Strength in Ovariectomized Mice. Nutrients. DOI: 10.3390/nu10111792

  12. Huang H (2020). Physiological and Transcriptomic Analysis of Fish Meal Replacement with Soy Protein Concentrate. Fish Physiology and Biochemistry. DOI: 10.1007/s10695-020-00851-3

  13. Yin J (2015). Dietary Protein and Amino Acid Profiles Affect Muscle Free Amino Acid Levels. Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology. DOI: 10.1186/s40104-015-0052-x

  14. Yin Y (2015). Effects of Dietary n-6:n-3 PUFA Ratio on Fatty Acid Composition and Gene Expression in Pigs. British Journal of Nutrition. DOI: 10.1017/S0007114514004346

  15. Médale F (2010). Effects of Plant Protein Sources on Skeletal Muscle Cellularity in Rainbow Trout. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology A. DOI: 10.1016/j.cbpa.2010.04.015

  16. Weiss WP (2021). Effects of Metabolizable Protein Concentration on Skeletal Muscle in Peripartum Dairy Cows. Journal of Dairy Science. DOI: 10.3168/jds.2021-20176

  17. Khara H (2024). Effects of Fermented Soybean Meal and Supplemental Methionine/Lysine on Growth and Amino Acid Composition in Beluga Fish. Journal of Animal Science. DOI: 10.1093/jas/skae275

  18. Rocha GC (2023). Effects of Crude Protein and Non-Essential Amino Acids on Growth Performance and Blood Profile in Piglets. Frontiers in Veterinary Science. DOI: 10.3389/fvets.2023.1243357

  19. Houlihan DF (2003). Proteomic Sensitivity to Dietary Manipulations in Rainbow Trout. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta. DOI: 10.1016/s1570-9639(03)00231-0

  20. Bakalli RI (2000). Influence of Dietary Protein Level on Response to Methionine and Betaine in Broiler Chickens. Poultry Science. DOI: 10.1093/ps/79.10.1478

INNER G
Previous

Balancing Strength Training with Cardio
Next

How Much Protein Should You Really Eat for Muscle Gain and Fat Loss? Optimal Intake and Key Insights